Florida Fence Test Results

The Florida Fence Test put 29 coating systems side by side on a salty beach for three years. Si-COAT 579 CM was the only one coat system in the test, and it came out on top.

Florida Power & Light, a major US power utility, ran the test through its own corrosion research laboratory. The aim was to find a coating that stops rust and holds its colour under fierce sun, without heavy surface preparation. CSL Silicones makes Si-COAT 579 CM, and TSS supplies it across Southern Africa, including the DRC and the Seychelles.

What the Florida Fence Test is

A fence test is about as real as testing gets. Coated steel panels sit on a rack outdoors, tilted at 45° and facing the sun. Meanwhile, salt spray, rain, heat and UV do their work, day after day.

This one ran at Melbourne Beach, Florida, for three full years. The site sits on the same beach as NASA’s corrosion test station at Cape Canaveral, about 72 km to the north. In fact, the utility copied NASA’s set up exactly, from the exposure angle to the salt spray and the sample preparation.

How the panels were prepared

The test was built around maintenance work, not new steel. First, the lab rusted the panels in a salt fog chamber. Then it hand cleaned them to SSPC SP2, which leaves tight rust on the surface, with no chlorides left behind. Finally, each maker’s coating went on exactly as its instructions said, primers included.

The line up included three coat and two coat epoxy and urethane systems, polysiloxane epoxy coatings, alkyds and organic zincs. In contrast, Si-COAT 579 CM went on as a single coat, with no primer. It went on at 0.18 mm dry film thickness (178 microns, 7 mil). After curing, every panel got an X cut through to bare metal, so rust had an easy way in.

Florida Fence Test results

After three years, the lab measured rust creep at the cut, as well as colour and gloss. The results split the field clearly.

Florida Fence Test panels after three years, with Si-COAT 579 CM on the right showing no rust creep
After three years. Left to right: a three coat epoxy system, an epoxy silicone two coat system and Si-COAT 579 CM.

Si-COAT 579 CM showed no rust creep at the cut, no bleed through and no loss of colour or gloss. The salt spray left a film of residue on it, but that wiped off easily.

Two alkyd coatings also held up well at the cut. However, both lost a lot of colour and gloss, and rust bled through and stained them. The other 26 systems showed heavy rust creep, colour loss or both. Even the polysiloxane epoxy coatings, then sold as the latest technology, failed the test.

From test panels to a working tank

The utility put the result to work straight away. In 2002, it coated a large fuel oil tank at its West Palm Beach terminal with Si-COAT 579 CM. Coastal humidity had rusted the old paint within five years, and the acrylic topcoat had faded badly.

The applicator spot primed the worst areas with 579 CM itself, then sprayed one coat to about 0.18 mm (7 mil). Where pitting had set in, the coat went on thicker, at about 0.3 mm (12 mil).

Why the Florida Fence Test matters in Southern Africa

Most corrosion work here happens on plants that are already running. Often, abrasive blasting isn’t allowed, or the cost and shutdown time rule it out. That is exactly what the Florida Fence Test copied: rusted steel, hand cleaned and coated once.

Coastal sites such as Durban and Richards Bay see the same mix of salt, heat and UV. Similarly, inland mines and chemical plants add dust and fumes to the load. For the full product details, see our silicone corrosion coating page, which also covers the C5 High system with CSL 979 primer. Next, read about real jobs at the Hoopstad fertiliser plant and the hopper in Durban harbour, or our guide to surface tolerant coating.

Send us the problem

Photos and a rough size are enough to start, while drawings and specs can follow later. Then we come back with the right product and a quote.

Scroll to Top